[wpkg-users] Trying out package upgrades before general roll-out of package

[Pendl Stefan]

Robin Roevens wrote:

Hi all

We have a general policy here that any new software update/-grade has to be tested by 4 to 5 people for some time before it is deployed over all affected computers.. But I'm having trouble to do that with WPKG.. :
If it is a new package, there is no problem.. those 4 to 5 people get that new package in their profile

But when it's about an update, I have  to create a duplicate of the current package, and change the name of the package, then change the name of that package in the profile applied to those test-users.. (ex. general package "firefox3" (containing ff 3.0.5) is copied, renamed and adapted to "firefox306" (containing ff 3.0.6)).

This approach is do-able when there are no other packages depending on it.. but the problems really starts when other packages do depend on it:
For example: we have a few firefox extension packages, firefox setting packages and also a Flash package depending on the firefox3 package.. So when I want to test a new firefox version/package I copy/rename the current firefox3 package to firefox306 and change it so it will install/upgrade to the newest firefox version..
I then change the profile of the test-users to contain firefox306 instead of firefox3 .. But then firefox3 is still pulled in by those other packages depending on it and thus downgrading the newly installed firefox306. So every WPKG run firefox306 is installed, then firefox3 is pulled in again and downgrades v306 again..

To prevent this from happening I have to copy and rename all packages depending on firefox3 and change those copies to depend on firefox306. Then change the profile of the test-users to contain those copies of all those other packages depending on firefox306..

Then after the test-period.. I replace the firefox3 package with the firefox306 package (renaming it again to firefox3) .. But then I also have to delete all those copies of dependant packages, and again change all those packages in the profile of those test-users...

This is a lot of manual work, and makes the package system difficult to manage during test-periods, and it is very easy to make errors..

It all wouldn't be such a big problem if the dependency system would be able to use virtuals instead of real package names, but that isn't the case so how do others perform test-drives on such kind of packages?  And/or is there something planned in a future WPKG version to make such cases easier?

Best regards

Robin

----

Robin,
     since there are only 4 to 5 test users, why not manually deploy the packages to them?
You could as well set up a test folder on the server containing the complete setup for testing, if the packages are proved, just copy them over to the production folder.

---
Stefan